Picture a school that introduces instructional coaching with real intent. Coaches are appointed, a schedule goes up, and every teacher is promised two visits a term. By the second half-term, something odd starts to happen. Teachers prepare “coaching lessons” the way they prepare for an inspection. The lesson the coach sees is the best lesson of the week, not a typical one. Feedback forms get filled in, attendance is high, and very little about everyday teaching changes.
Most school leaders will recognize some version of this. It points to the central problem with many coaching programmes. Teachers rarely reject help. What they push back against is judgement that has been given a friendlier name.
So the real design question for an instructional coaching model goes beyond what coaches should do. Leaders also need to ask what would make a teacher want the coach in the room on an ordinary Tuesday.
Teachers Can Tell Support From Surveillance Within Weeks
At its simplest, instructional coaching is a repeated conversation between a teacher and a more experienced colleague about one specific part of practice. The teacher tries something, and the two look at the result together. On paper, the model sounds supportive. In practice, teachers judge it by a few quiet signals.
Who sees the notes? Who chose the focus? Does the coach arrive with a checklist or with a question? Has anything said in a coaching session ever turned up in a performance review?
If the honest answers point towards monitoring, teachers will act as if they are being monitored. They will show safe lessons, agree politely and change little. Better training for coaches will not fix that, because the problem sits in how the programme is designed.
Keep the Coaching Conversation Out of the Appraisal File
The most important design decision is the boundary between coaching and evaluation. Schools need both. A school still has to make judgements about teaching quality, and it should. But when one conversation serves both development and appraisal, the teacher has every reason to hide the very problems coaching is meant to work on.
A workable rule is simple. What is said in coaching stays in coaching, unless there is a safeguarding or serious conduct concern. Evaluation can run on its own evidence and its own timetable. Leaders rethinking this boundary can look at teacher evaluation frameworks built for growth. The two systems work best when they are designed together and kept clearly apart.
If a teacher would rewrite tomorrow’s lesson the night before the coach arrives, is the coach seeing teaching at all, or only a performance of it?
Start With the Teacher’s Question, Not the Coach’s Checklist
Many coaching models begin with a school-wide focus: questioning this term, routines the next. A shared focus has value. But when it is the only way in, coaching turns into policy delivery and stops being help with a problem the teacher actually has.
A more welcome model lets the teacher name the issue. “My Year 8 group can follow the worked examples but freeze on the first unfamiliar problem.” “Half the class finish early and drift.” These are real classroom problems. A teacher who has named one is already invested in solving it.
The coach’s skill is to narrow that problem down to something small enough to work on in a fortnight. This is where coaching starts to feel useful rather than ceremonial. It also fits naturally within an everyday feedback culture, where feedback is part of a normal week and not something that arrives twice a term.

Put Student Evidence Between the Coach and the Teacher
Coaching conversations go wrong when they become the coach’s opinion against the teacher’s experience. “I felt the pace was slow” invites defense. “Let’s look at what these six students wrote on the exit task” invites curiosity.
When student work or assessment evidence is on the table, coach and teacher are looking at the same thing from the same side. The question moves from “how did you do?” to “what did the students learn, and what should we try next?” That lowers the stakes for the teacher and raises the quality of the discussion.
This only works when the evidence is specific. A class average says very little. Knowing that most students can recall a method but struggle to apply it gives coach and teacher something concrete to plan around. Teachers who are confident reading evidence at this level get more out of coaching, which is why assessment data literacy for teachers belongs in the same professional learning plan.
One Change, Short Cycles
Coaching often fails because it asks for too much. A feedback conversation that ends with eight action points usually produces none, because the teacher has thirty other things to do before Friday.
A good cycle ends with one change the teacher can try within days, plus a clear plan for what to look at next time to see whether it worked. Short cycles keep the work close to the classroom. They also give teachers early proof that the effort is worth it, and that early proof is often what turns a skeptical teacher into a willing one.
Who Coaches Matters as Much as How
Teachers welcome coaches they trust. That trust usually rests on three things. The coach still understands classroom reality. The coach is not the teacher’s line manager. And the coach has shown they can keep a confidence.
These conditions create real choices for leaders. A senior leader who line-manages a department may be a poor coach for that same department, however skilled they are. A respected middle leader with protected time may be a better choice. New teachers need different handling again, with more structure and more reassurance, which is the focus of induction and coaching for early-career teachers. Schools that take coaching seriously also have to develop the people who coach, and that connects to developing instructional leaders who can improve teaching.
What Leaders Should Check Before Scaling a Coaching Model
Before rolling a model out across a school or a group of schools, leaders can test it with a few honest questions:
- Do teachers know, in writing, what happens to coaching notes?
- Can teachers choose or shape the focus?
- Does every cycle end with one change and a plan to look at evidence again?
- Do coaches have protected time, or is coaching squeezed into gaps?
- Are coaches trained to ask, or only to tell?
- Are leaders measuring whether practice and student evidence are shifting, or only counting visits?
The last question matters most at group level. Visit counts are easy to report and say almost nothing about impact. A network that tracks only completion will get completion.
If a coaching programme hit every visit target this year, what evidence would tell you it changed a single lesson?
The Test Is Whether Teachers Ask for It
A coaching model earns its welcome when teachers can see that it protects them, starts from their problems, works from real evidence about their students and asks for small, achievable changes. None of that needs a large budget. It needs leaders to make a few clear design decisions and hold to them, above all the line between support and judgement.
In a year’s time, are your teachers asking for coaching, or just accepting it?
FAQs
What is an instructional coaching model?
An instructional coaching model is a structured, repeated process in which a teacher works with a more experienced colleague on one specific part of their practice. Each cycle usually involves agreeing a focus, trying a change in class and looking at the results together.
Why do teachers resist instructional coaching?
Teachers usually resist coaching that feels like evaluation under another name. Common warning signs include unclear rules about who sees coaching notes, a focus chosen without the teacher’s input and feedback that ends in long lists of actions.
Should instructional coaching be linked to teacher evaluation?
Most coaching models work better when coaching conversations are kept separate from appraisal. Teachers are more open about their real classroom problems when they know those conversations will not appear in a performance review.
How long should an instructional coaching cycle last?
There is no single correct length. Short cycles of a few weeks, each ending with one change to try and a plan for reviewing evidence, keep coaching close to everyday teaching and help teachers see results sooner.
How can school leaders tell whether coaching is working?
Counting visits shows activity, not impact. More useful signs are whether teachers are trying new practices, whether student work or assessment evidence is changing, and whether teachers ask for coaching voluntarily.
Who should be an instructional coach in a school?
A good coach understands classroom realities, can keep a confidence and is ideally not the teacher’s line manager. Respected middle leaders with protected time often make strong coaches.