KODEIT Ascend KODEITAscend

Which Learning Analytics Should Change a School Leader’s Next Decision?

Uncategorized
Which Learning Analytics Should Change a School Leader's Next Decision?

Picture the October data meeting at a middle school in the Midwest. This school is a hypothetical example. The fall benchmark results are on the screen, the average reading score is up two points on last spring, and the slide is green. The conversation moves on quickly.

Nobody asks which students produced those two points. Nobody checks whether the same students sat both tests. Nobody asks whether the students who started the year furthest behind moved at all.

That meeting is not unusual. The problem is not a shortage of data, because most US principals and district leaders have more dashboards than they can read. What they often lack is a filter: a way to tell which numbers deserve action and which only describe activity.

Here is the short answer. The learning analytics that should change a school leader’s next decision are the ones that would change how time, people or money are used if the number moved. In practice, that usually means five kinds of evidence:

  • how results are spread across students
  • growth compared with similar students or schools
  • participation and attendance, read beside scores
  • skill patterns across classrooms
  • what changed after an intervention

A Useful Metric Has to Point at a Decision

Before any number goes on a leadership slide, ask one plain question: if this figure went up or down by a meaningful amount, what would we do differently?

If the honest answer is “nothing,” the metric may still be interesting. It is just not decision data. Logins, the number of assessments completed, and a school-wide average with no context usually fail this test. They tell leaders that something happened, but they rarely tell leaders what to do next.

Decision data points at a group of students, a grade, a skill or a strategy, and it suggests a move. That move might be to add coaching, regroup students, change the schedule, keep going, or stop.

The Average Is Where Problems Hide

The national picture shows why an average needs context. On the 2024 NAEP reading assessment, 40 percent of US fourth graders scored below the NAEP Basic level, a larger share than in 2022, and fourth-grade scores fell at every selected percentile except the 90th, where the top performers held steady. nationsreportcard

NAEP is a national sample, so it says nothing directly about any single school. The pattern is still a useful warning. A decline concentrated among lower-performing students can look small in an average. An average that rises can hide a bottom quarter that is sliding.

For a principal, the practical step is to look at the spread before the mean. How many students sit in each performance band? Did the lowest quarter move? This is also why leaders should weigh growth versus attainment rather than treating a high score as proof that a school is working.

Growth Against Similar Schools Shows Whether Practice Is Working

The 2026 Education Scorecard comes from researchers at Harvard, Stanford and Dartmouth. It links state test results for about 35 million US students in grades 3–8, from 2022 to 2025, to a common national scale. One of its clearest findings is that recovery varied sharply even among districts with similar students. The team identified 108 districts that improved strongly in reading and math compared with matched peers of similar size, demographics, poverty level and urbanicity.

The study works at district level, and on its own it does not show which practices caused those gains. The lesson for leaders is still clear. Comparing a school with schools that serve very different students mostly measures who enrolls. Comparing growth among similar students or campuses starts to show whether teaching and support are making a difference.

In a district or charter network, this changes the question from “which school scored highest?” to “which school moved its students furthest from where they started?”

If two campuses post the same average, but one has moved its lowest readers and the other has not, which principal should the rest of the network be learning from?

Read Participation and Attendance Before You Read the Score

A score only describes the students who were there to produce it. The same Scorecard reports that 23 percent of students were chronically absent in 2024–2025. That is below the post-pandemic peak but still above the 15 percent seen before the pandemic. The researchers estimate that if absence rates had returned to pre-pandemic levels, recovery would have been 0.03 to 0.05 grade equivalents larger in districts at all income levels. harvard

This matters to a school leader in two ways. First, a grade-level result with 82% test completion is weaker evidence than one with 98% completion, especially if the missing students are the ones most likely to struggle. Checking for assessment participation bias should come before any interpretation. Second, attendance is a leading indicator. It moves weeks before test scores do, and it points at actions a leader controls, such as family outreach, scheduling and mentoring.

Skill Patterns Across Classrooms Show Where Support Belongs

A weak grade-level score tells a leader that something is wrong. It does not say what kind of support will help. The pattern underneath the score does.

Take a hypothetical seventh-grade math team. If three of four classes struggle with proportional reasoning, the cause is probably curriculum, sequencing or shared planning, and the response belongs at team level: common planning time or targeted coaching. If only one class struggles, the conversation is with one teacher, and it is about support rather than blame. If weak results are scattered across individuals in every class, small-group intervention is likely the better move.

The same score leads to three different decisions. That is why standard-level and skill-level evidence belongs in leadership meetings. It is also why turning assessment results into instructional decisions has to happen at the level where teaching is actually planned.

The Question Most Dashboards Never Answer: Did It Work?

Most school data systems report well on the last assessment window. Fewer are set up to answer the question leaders need answered six weeks later: did the change we made actually move anything?

Answering it takes some discipline when the decision is made. When a leader approves an intervention, the team should agree on four things:

  • which students are included
  • which skill is targeted
  • which follow-up check will judge the result
  • when that check will happen

Without that agreement, the next benchmark arrives and nobody can say whether the new reading block, the tutoring or the regrouping made a difference. Building this check into your school improvement KPIs for leadership teams keeps improvement work honest.

What to Take Off the First Slide

Some numbers are comfortable to report and easy to explain to a school board. Usage counts, assessments administered, and averages ranked from top to bottom all fall into this group. None of them is wrong to track, but they should not lead the meeting.

If a figure on your dashboard doubled overnight, would anyone’s plan for Monday morning change? If not, why is it on the first slide?

Five Questions to Ask Before the Next Data Meeting

  • Who is missing from this data, and could their absence change the story?
  • How is performance spread, and did the lowest band move?
  • Are we comparing growth among similar students or schools, or just ranking scores?
  • At what skill or standard level does the problem sit, and is it one class or many?
  • What did we change last cycle, and has anything moved since?

Data Earns Its Place When It Changes Something

The goal of learning analytics in a school is not a better dashboard. The goal is a better next decision about who gets help, what gets retaught, where coaching goes, and whether last month’s plan deserves another month. A leadership team that asks these questions of every number will end up needing fewer numbers, and it will use them better.


FAQs

What are learning analytics for school leaders?
They are assessment, attendance and participation data organized to support leadership decisions. Useful learning analytics show where students are, how they are growing, and where support should go next. They are more than a summary of past test results.

Which data should a principal review first after a benchmark assessment?
Start with participation: who tested and who did not. Then look at how scores are spread across performance bands. Then look at growth from the last cycle. Only after that should you review averages and comparisons.

Why is an average test score not enough for decision-making?
An average can stay flat or even rise while the lowest-performing students fall further behind. The 2024 NAEP reading results showed declines concentrated below the top performers, which a single average can easily hide.

How does chronic absenteeism affect assessment data?
Students who miss school often miss assessments too, which can make results look stronger than they really are. Absence also slows learning. Researchers estimate that US recovery since 2022 would have been larger if absence rates had returned to pre-pandemic levels.

What is the difference between growth data and attainment data?
Attainment shows where students are at a point in time. Growth shows how far they moved between assessments. Growth is usually the better guide to whether teaching and intervention are working.

How often should school leaders review learning analytics?
Most US schools review academic data at each benchmark window (fall, winter and spring). Attendance and participation can be checked more often, because they change faster and give earlier warning.

Where KODEIT Ascend Fits

Scholario Ascend is built around the same idea: evidence should lead to a decision, and that decision should be checked. Its leadership views show participation beside performance and rank schools by growth as well as attainment. Leaders can move from the network or school level down through grade, class, subject and competency to the skill where teaching decisions are made. Assessment cycles can be placed side by side to show change since the last cycle, and averages are reported with range and standard deviation so the spread stays visible. The aim is to help leaders see where to act, and then see whether that action moved anything.

FAQ

Who is this article for?
School leaders, curriculum coordinators, and teachers looking for practical ways to strengthen learning beyond one-off theme weeks.
How does KODEIT Ascend support this approach?
KODEIT Ascend provides structured units, classroom routines, and progress visibility so community learning becomes part of the weekly rhythm u2014 not a special event.
Can families be involved?
Yes. Share classroom learning goals in simple language and invite families to extend conversations at home with everyday examples from your community.

← Back to Blog