KODEIT Ascend KODEITAscend

Developing Instructional Leaders Who Improve Teaching, Not Just Manage It

Curriculum Leadership
Developing Instructional Leaders Who Improve Teaching, Not Just Manage It

It is the last leadership meeting of term. The head of science reports that every teacher in the department has been observed twice, all feedback forms are filed, and the department plan is on track. Everyone nods. Nobody asks the question that matters most: what is happening differently in those science lessons now, and are students learning more because of it?

That gap sits at the center of instructional leadership. It is the difference between activity that looks like leadership and leadership that changes teaching. Most schools do not lack organized, hard-working leaders. What they often lack is leaders who can take evidence from classrooms, work out what it means, and help a teacher change one specific thing.

The short answer for anyone designing an instructional leadership development programme is that it should train leaders in three things:

  1. Diagnosing teaching and learning problems from evidence.
  2. Giving feedback that teachers can act on.
  3. Checking whether the change improved learning.

Training in policy, process and compliance still has value. On its own, though, it produces managers of teaching, not people who improve it.

Why Good Teachers Often Become Leaders Who Manage Rather Than Improve

Most middle leaders are promoted because they were excellent teachers. But being skilled in your own classroom is a different skill from improving someone else’s. Nobody automatically learns the second skill on the day they get the new job title.

The new role then fills up quickly with timetables, cover, parent issues, data deadlines and appraisal paperwork. The training on offer usually matches those demands: how the appraisal cycle works, how to handle a difficult conversation, how to complete the department review. All of it is useful. A department with chaotic systems will struggle to improve anything.

The problem starts when management becomes the whole job, and success is measured by completion. Observations done, forms filed, deadlines met.

If a head of department completed every scheduled observation this year, and no teacher in the department changed anything about their practice, what exactly was led?

Managing Teaching and Improving Teaching Can Look the Same From a Distance

The two kinds of leadership often involve the same activities. The difference lies in what the leader is looking for and what happens afterwards.

Leadership activityWhen it manages teachingWhen it improves teaching
Lesson observationChecks the lesson against a checklist or rating scaleLooks for one high-impact issue linked to what students are learning
FeedbackLong written form with many points, filed afterwardsOne specific change, agreed in conversation and revisited within weeks
Data meetingsReviews averages and flags weaker classesAsks which skill, which students, and whether the cause is the curriculum, the teaching or the test
Curriculum oversightConfirms the scheme of work is covered on timeChecks whether sequencing and depth are producing secure learning
Measure of successTasks completed on scheduleVisible change in practice, then in student learning
Leader’s timeMostly meetings and adminProtected time in classrooms and with teachers

Nothing in the right-hand column needs more meetings. What it needs is leaders who know what to look for and what to do next.

The Skill That Rarely Gets Taught: Finding Where the Problem Sits

Take a hypothetical case. Two Grade 7 maths classes follow the same scheme of work and sit the same assessment. One class performs much worse on proportional reasoning.

A leader in management mode often responds by booking extra observations of the weaker class’s teacher. An instructional leader asks some questions first:

  • Do both classes struggle with the same skill? If they do, the cause is probably upstream: the sequencing, the curriculum time, or the way the questions were written. If only one class struggles, the cause is more local. That is often useful news, because something is working in the other room and can be shared.
  • Did most students choose the same wrong answer? If so, that suggests one shared misconception. One misconception needs one well-planned lesson, not a term of intervention.
  • Do students know the content but fail when they have to apply it? That is a different problem. It calls for practice, not reteaching.
  • Did every student sit the assessment? If some did not, the class result may not show what it seems to show.

This is where assessment literacy becomes a leadership skill rather than a data-team task. A leader who cannot tell a curriculum problem from a classroom problem will keep sending support to the wrong place. For a closer look at which numbers should actually prompt action, see which learning analytics should change a leader’s decision.

Feedback a Teacher Can Act On Tomorrow Morning

Teachers rarely improve from a list of twelve development points. They improve when a leader names one change, explains why it matters for these particular students, and comes back to see how it went.

That sounds simple. In practice, it is one of the hardest leadership skills to learn. It means choosing what not to mention. It means describing what students did rather than judging the teacher. And it means agreeing a next step small enough to try in tomorrow’s lesson.

Leaders need to rehearse this, not just hear about it. Schools that build feedback into regular coaching, rather than tying it to appraisal, tend to make this easier. Feedback feels like support, not a verdict. The design choices behind that are explored in designing an instructional coaching model.

Building an Instructional Leadership Development Programme Around Real Decisions

Developing instructional leaders works best when the programme looks less like a course and more like supervised practice. Five design principles make the difference:

  1. Use the school’s own evidence. Leaders should bring their department’s latest assessment results, student work and observation notes. Generic case studies are easy to agree with and easy to forget.
  2. Practise the diagnosis before the action. Most leaders jump straight to “what intervention should we run?” The programme should slow that down and rehearse the question “where does this problem actually sit?”
  3. Rehearse feedback conversations, with feedback on the feedback. Role-play, recorded practice and peers watching each other give feedback all build instructional leadership skills faster than reading about them.
  4. Protect classroom time. A programme that adds hours but removes no admin will fail quietly. Senior leaders have to decide which tasks middle leaders will stop doing.
  5. Judge the programme by what changed in classrooms. Attendance and certificates are not outcomes. The real test is whether teachers in each leader’s team changed their practice, and whether student evidence moved over the following assessment cycles.

This works best as part of a longer route, not a one-off course. Strong schools connect it to how they spot and grow future leaders early, which is the focus of school leadership pipeline. The wider shift towards coaching-based, evidence-informed leadership is covered in trends in instructional leadership.

If you gave all your heads of department the same set of class results, how many would ask what students misunderstood before asking which teacher is weakest?

Questions to Ask Before Funding the Next Leadership Programme

  • Which real decisions will participants practise, and using whose evidence?
  • How will we know whether teaching changed in their teams?
  • Which existing tasks will we remove to give them the time?
  • Does the programme build assessment and data literacy, or simply assume leaders already have it?
  • Who supports and coaches these leaders after the course ends?

If a provider, or your own CPD team, cannot answer these clearly, the programme is likely to produce better-informed managers rather than better instructional leaders.

Leadership That Shows Up in the Next Assessment Cycle

Management keeps a school running, and no school can do without it. Instructional leadership is what moves learning forward. Back in that end-of-term meeting, a stronger report might sound like this: “Two teachers changed how they introduce ratio problems after we found a shared misconception, and the next assessment shows the gap narrowing in both classes.”

That kind of sentence is the real goal of developing instructional leaders. It is specific, it is based on evidence, and it is about students.


FAQs

What is instructional leadership in schools?
Instructional leadership means leading to improve teaching and learning, not only running school systems. Instructional leaders use evidence to diagnose learning problems, give teachers focused feedback, support changes in classroom practice, and check whether student learning improves as a result.

What is the difference between instructional leadership and school management?
School management keeps operations running: timetables, policies, compliance and deadlines. Instructional leadership focuses on the quality of teaching and what students learn. Schools need both, but a leader who only manages may complete every task without any change in classroom practice.

What should an instructional leadership development programme include?
It should include practice in diagnosing problems using the school’s own assessment evidence, rehearsed feedback and coaching conversations, protected classroom time, and follow-up coaching. The programme should be judged by changes in teaching practice and student learning, not by attendance.

How can a school tell whether its instructional leadership development is working?
Look for changes in what teachers in each leader’s team actually do differently. Then check whether student evidence improves across later assessment cycles. Completion rates, observation counts and course certificates show activity, not impact.

Do instructional leaders need assessment data skills?
Yes. Leaders need to read results well enough to tell whether a problem comes from the curriculum, the teaching, the assessment itself, or who took the test. Without that skill, support and resources often go to the wrong place.

Where KODEIT Ascend Fits

One of the hardest instructional leadership skills is telling a curriculum problem from a classroom problem. This is a distinction Scholario Ascend is designed to make visible. Within its school leaders view, classes in the same grade can be compared side by side on accuracy, gap and mastery. Performance is reported against the competency framework, with standard codes, and participation is shown beside performance. Leaders can also see results against the school's own previous assessment cycles and follow whether an intervention actually moved anything. Because teachers and leaders read the same evidence at different levels of detail, diagnosis and feedback conversations can start from shared facts. The professional judgement stays with the leader.

FAQ

Who is this article for?
School leaders, curriculum coordinators, and teachers looking for practical ways to strengthen learning beyond one-off theme weeks.
How does KODEIT Ascend support this approach?
KODEIT Ascend provides structured units, classroom routines, and progress visibility so community learning becomes part of the weekly rhythm u2014 not a special event.
Can families be involved?
Yes. Share classroom learning goals in simple language and invite families to extend conversations at home with everyday examples from your community.

← Back to Blog